Maha Abdel Rahim criminal case has been pending for over two years in the Riverside Superior Court with no end in sight

In general criminal trials are speedily disposed of as the criminal defendant has the right to a speedy trial. However, In Maha Abdel Rahim’s case  her criminal case has been pending for over two years after the initial complaint was filed on 1/9/2013 by the Riverside County District Attorney’s office, for Felony violation of CA penal code 278.5.  The docket shows 5 trial court readiness hearings, 2 preliminary hearings, and 2 felony settlement conferences.

In addition, Judge Becky Dugan, set a trial on 02/23/2015, it was vacated and another trial court readiness conference was set in violation of CA penal code section 1382 (a)(2)(b) which states that the defendant shall be brought to trial on the date set for trial or within 10 days thereafter.

(B) The defendant requests or consents to the setting of a trial
date beyond the 60-day period. In the absence of an express general
time waiver from the defendant, or upon the withdrawal of a general
time waiver, the court shall set a trial date. Whenever a case is set
for trial beyond the 60-day period by request or consent, expressed
or implied, of the defendant without a general waiver, the defendant
shall be brought to trial on the date set for trial or within 10 days
thereafter.

Under California law a delay of one year can create a presumption of prejudice. (Id. at pp. 655-656; People v. Williams (2013) 58 Cal.4th 197, 234-235 [seven year delay in bringing a capital case was presumptively prejudicial].(http://www.sdap.org/downloads/research/criminal/jg14.pdf).

CA penal code section 1382 (a)(2)(A) specifies that unless the defendant enters a 60 day trial waiver the sanction of dismissal may apply.

 (A) The defendant enters a general waiver of the 60-day trial
requirement. A general waiver of the 60-day trial requirement
entitles the superior court to set or continue a trial date without
the sanction of dismissal should the case fail to proceed on the date
set for trial. If the defendant, after proper notice to all parties,
later withdraws, in open court, his or her waiver in the superior
court, the defendant shall be brought to trial within 60 days of the
date of that withdrawal. Upon the withdrawal of a general time waiver
in open court, a trial date shall be set and all parties shall be
properly notified of that date. If a general time waiver is not
expressly entered, subparagraph (B) shall apply.

Maha has not seen her son in over two years due to the unreasonable and prejudicial delay of the criminal case. Any parent can identify with that pain and suffering. The Eighth Amendment of the US constitution prohibits cruel and unusual punishment.

Clipboard01

Clipboard02

Clipboard03

Clipboard04

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s